HA07-IV.txt
CONVENTION (IV) RESPECTING THE
LAWS AND CUSTOMS
OF WAR ON LAND
Signed at The Hague, 18
October 1907.
ENTRY INTO FORCE:
26 January 1910
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Article
Purpose of Convention preamble
Instructions
to armed forces 1
Powers bound 2
Penalty for
violating regulations 3
Prior Convention
replaced
4
Continuance of former Convention
Ratification
5
Deposit at The Hague
Certified copies to Powers
Adherence
of non-signatory Powers 6
Notification of intent
Communication
to other Powers
Effect of ratification 7
Denunciation 8
Notifying Power only
affected
Register of ratifications 9
Signing
Deposit
of original
ANNEX TO THE CONVENTION
Regulations respecting the laws and customs of war on
land
SECTION I
On
Belligerents
Chapter I - The Qualifications of belligerents
Application of laws of war to all
forces 1
Levee en masse 2
Combatants and non-combatants 3
Chapter
II - Prisoners of War.
Responsibility of capturing Government 4
Treatment
Personal
belongings
Confinements 5
Employment at labour
6
Payment
Use of wages
Maintenance 7
General treatment
Subject to military laws, etc. 8
Insubordination
Recaptured
prisoners
Restrictions for
false statements
9
Parole to be
observed
10
Parole to be
voluntary 11
Forfeiture of parole
12
Treatment of
captured reporters, sutlers, etc.
13
Bureau of
information to be established 14
Receipt, etc., of property
Recognition of relief societies 15
Privileges allowed 16
Pay to officers taken prisoners 17
Religious liberty 18
Wills
19
Burials, etc.
Repatriation 20
Chapter
III - The Sick and Wounded .
Geneva Convention to govern 21
SECTION II
On Hostilities
Chapter I -
Means of Injuring the Enemy, Sieges, and Bombardments.
Restriction 22
Special Prohibitions 23
a) Poison
b) Treachery
c)
Killing those who have surrendered
d) Quarter
e) Weapons
causing unnecessary suffering
f)
Abuse of flags and uniform
g)
Unnecessary destruction or seizure of property
h) Rights and actions
Forced service against one's own country
Obtaining information permitted 24
Assault on undefended towns, etc. 25
Warning of bombardments 26
Buildings etc. to be spared 27
Notification of
Pillage prohibited 28
Chapter II
- Spies.
Definitions
29
Trial
required 30
Subsequent capture 31
Chapter III
- Flags of Truce.
Inviolability of parlementaire 32
Reception not compulsory 33
Treason of parlementaire 34
Chapter
IV - Capitulations.
Military honour to be observed 35
Chapter V -
Armistices.
Effect
36
General or
local 37
Notification 38
Communication allowed with inhabitants 39
Effect of violation by Powers 40
Violation by private persons 41
SECTION
III
Military Authority
over the Territory of the Hostile State
Actual occupation 42
Extent
Preservation of order and
safety
43
Forcing
information from inhabitants forbidden 44
Requiring oath of allegiance forbidden 45
Rights and property to be respected 46
No
confiscation
Pillage
forbidden 47
Collection of taxes
48
Levies for
military needs 49
General penalty for acts of individuals
forbidden 50
Collection of contributions 51
Requisitions for needs of army 52
Seizure of public cash, property etc. 53
Submarine cables to neutral territory 54
Administration of public property in
occupied territory 55
Municipal, religious etc. property 56
Legal proceedings for seizure etc.
SECTION IV
On the Internment of Belligerents
and the Care of the Wounded in
Neutral Countries
Confinement of belligerents in neutral territory 57
Food, clothing etc.
58
Reimbursements
Transit of wounded or sick through neutral
territory 59
Neutral State must furnish guard
Geneva Convention applicable 60
---------**************---------
CONVENTION (IV) RESPECTING THE
LAWS AND CUSTOMS
OF WAR ON LAND
Signed at The Hague, 18
October 1907.
Seeing that, while seeking means to preserve
peace and prevent armed
conflicts between nations, it is likewise
necessary to bear in mind the
case where the appeal to arms has been
brought about by events which their
care was unable to avert;
Animated
by the desire to serve, even in this extreme case, the interests
of
humanity and the ever progressive needs of civilization;
Thinking it
important, with this object, to revise the general laws and
customs of
war, either with a view to defining them with greater precision
or to
confining them within such limits as would mitigate their severity as
far
as possible;
Have deemed it necessary to complete and explain in
certain particulars the
work of the First Peace Conference, which,
following on the Brussels
Conference of 1874, and inspired by the ideas
dictated by a wise and
generous forethought, adopted provisions intended
to define and govern the
usages of war on land.
According to
the views of the High Contracting Parties, these provisions,
the wording
of which has been inspired by the desire to diminish the evils
of war, as
far as military requirements permit, are intended to serve as a
general
rule of conduct for the belligerents in their mutual relations and
in
their relations with the inhabitants.
It has not, however, been
found possible at present to concert regulations
covering all the
circumstances which arise in practice;
On the other hand, the High
Contracting Parties clearly do not intend that
unforeseen cases should, in
the absence of a written undertaking, be left
to the arbitrary judgment of
military commanders.
Until a more complete code of the laws of war
has been issued, the High
Contracting Parties deem it expedient to declare
that, in cases not
included in the Regulations adopted by them, the
inhabitants and the
belligerents remain under the protection and the rule
of the principles of
the law of nations, as they result from the usages
established among
civilized peoples, from the laws of humanity, and the
dictates of the
public conscience.
They declare that it is in
this sense especially that Articles 1 and 2 of
the Regulations adopted
must be understood.
The High Contracting Parties, wishing to
conclude afresh Convention to this
effect, have appointed the following as
their Plenipotentiaries:
(Here follow the names of Plenipotentiaries)
Who, after
having deposited their full powers, found in good and due form,
have
agreed upon the following:
Article 1. The Contracting Powers shall
issue instructions to their armed
land forces which shall be in conformity
with the Regulations respecting
the laws and customs of war on land,
annexed to the present Convention.
Art. 2. The provisions contained
in the Regulations referred to in Article
1, as well as in the present
Convention, do not apply except between
Contracting Powers, and then only
if all the belligerents are parties to
the Convention.
Art. 3.
A belligerent party which violates the provisions of the said
Regulations
shall, if the case demands, be liable to pay compensation It
shall be
responsible for all acts committed by persons forming part of its
armed
forces.
Art. 4. The present Convention, duly ratified, shall as
between the
Contracting Powers, be substituted for the Convention of 29
July 1899,
respecting the laws and customs of war on land.
The
Convention of 1899 remains in force as between the Powers which signed
it,
and which do not also ratify the present Convention.
Art. 5. The
present Convention shall be ratified as soon as possible.
The
ratifications shall be deposited at The Hague.
The first deposit of
ratifications shall be recorded in a procs-verbal
signed by the
Representatives of the Powers which take part therein and by
the
Netherlands Minister for Foreign Affairs.
The subsequent deposits of
ratifications shall be made by means of a
written notification, addressed
to the Netherlands Government and
accompanied by the instrument of
ratification.
A duly certified copy of the procs-verbal relative to
the first deposit of
ratifications, of the notifications mentioned in the
preceding paragraph,
as well as of the instruments of ratification, shall
be immediately sent by
the Netherlands Government, through the diplomatic
channel, to the Powers
invited to the Second Peace Conference, as well as
to the other Powers
which have adhered to the Convention. In the cases
contemplated in the
preceding paragraph the said Government shall at the
same time inform them
of the date on which it received the
notification.
Art. 6. Non-Signatory Powers may adhere to the present
Convention.
The Power which desires to adhere notifies in writing
its intention to the
Netherlands Government, forwarding to it the act of
adhesion, which shall
be deposited in the archives of the said
Government.
This Government shall at once transmit to all the other
Powers a duly
certified copy of the notification as well as of the act of
adhesion,
mentioning the date on which it received the notification.
Art.
7. The present Convention shall come into force, in the case of the
Powers
which were a party to the first deposit of ratifications, sixty days
after
the date of the procs-verbal of this deposit, and, in the case of
the
Powers which ratify subsequently or which adhere, sixty days after the
notification
of their ratification or of their adhesion has been received
by the
Netherlands Government.
Art. 8. In the event of one of the
Contracting Powers wishing to denounce
the present Convention, the
denunciation shall be notified in writing to
the Netherlands Government,
which shall at once communicate a duly
certified copy of the notification
to all the other Powers, informing them
of the date on which it was
received.
The denunciation shall only have effect in regard to the
notifying Power,
and one year after the notification has reached the
Netherlands Government.
Art. 9. A register kept by the Netherlands
Ministry for Foreign Affairs
shall give the date of the deposit of
ratifications made in virtue of
Article 5, paragraphs 3 and 4, as well as
the date on which the
notifications of adhesion (Article 6, paragraph 2),
or of denunciation
(Article 8, paragraph 1) were received.
Each
Contracting Power is entitled to have access to this register and to
be
supplied with duly certified extracts.
In faith whereof the
Plenipotentiaries have appended their signatures to
the present
Convention.
Done at The Hague 18 October 1907, in a single copy,
which shall remain
deposited in the archives of the Netherlands
Government, and duly certified
copies of which shall be sent, through the
diplomatic channel to the Powers
which have been invited to the Second
Peace Conference.
(Here follow signatures)
Annex to the
Convention
REGULATIONS RESPECTING THE LAWS AND CUSTOMS
OF WAR ON
LAND
SECTION I
ON
BELLIGERENTS
CHAPTER I
The Qualifications of
Belligerents
Article 1. The laws, rights, and duties of war apply
not only to armies,
but also to militia and volunteer corps fulfilling the
following
conditions:
1. To be commanded by a
person responsible for his subordinates;
2. To have a fixed
distinctive emblem recognizable at a distance;
3. To carry arms openly;
and
4. To conduct their operations in accordance with the laws and
customs
of war.
In
countries where militia or volunteer corps constitute the army, or form
part
of it, they are included under the denomination "army."
Art.
2. The inhabitants of a territory which has not been occupied, who, on
the
approach of the enemy, spontaneously take up arms to resist the
invading
troops without having had time to organize themselves in
accordance with
Article 1, shall be regarded as belligerents if they carry
arms openly and
if they respect the laws and customs of war.
Art. 3. The armed
forces of the belligerent parties may consist of
combatants and
non-combatants. In the case of capture by the enemy, both
have a right to
be treated as prisoners of war.
CHAPTER II
Prisoners of
War
Art. 4. Prisoners of war are in the power of the hostile Government,
but
not of the individuals or corps who capture them.
They must
be humanely treated.
All their personal belongings, except arms,
horses, and military papers,
remain their property.
Art. 5.
Prisoners of war may be interned in a town, fortress, camp, or
other
place, and bound not to go beyond certain fixed limits, but they
cannot be
confined except as in indispensable measure of safety and only
while the
circumstances which necessitate the measure continue to exist.
Art.
6. The State may utilize the labour of prisoners of war according to
their
rank and aptitude, officers excepted. The tasks shall not be
excessive and
shall have no connection with the operations of the war.
Prisoners
may be authorized to work for the public service, for private
persons, or
on their own account.
Work done for the State is paid for at the
rates in force for work of a
similar kind done by soldiers of the national
army, or, if there are none
in force, at a rate according to the work
executed.
When the work is for other branches of the public service
or for private
persons the conditions are settled in agreement with the
military
authorities.
The wages of the prisoners shall go
towards improving their position, and
the balance shall be paid them on
their release, after deducting the cost
of their maintenance.
Art.
7. The Government into whose hands prisoners of war have fallen is
charged
with their maintenance.
In the absence of a special agreement
between the belligerents, prisoners
of war shall be treated as regards
board, lodging, and clothing on the same
footing as the troops of the
Government who captured them.
Art. 8. Prisoners of war shall be
subject to the laws, regulations, and
orders in force in the army of the
State in whose power they are. Any act
of insubordination justifies the
adoption towards them of such measures of
severity as may be considered
necessary.
Escaped prisoners who are retaken before being able to
rejoin their own
army or before leaving the territory occupied by the army
which captured
them are liable to disciplinary punishment.
Prisoners
who, after succeeding in escaping, are again taken prisoners, are
not
liable to any punishment on account of the previous flight.
Art. 9.
Every prisoner of war is bound to give, if he is questioned on the
subject,
his true name and rank, and if he infringes this rule, he is
liable to
have the advantages given to prisoners of his class curtailed.
Art.
10. Prisoners of war may be set at liberty on parole if the laws of
their
country allow, and, in such cases, they are bound, on their personal
honour,
scrupulously to fulfil, both towards their own Government and the
Government
by whom they were made prisoners, the engagements they have
contracted.
In
such cases their own Government is bound neither to require of nor
accept
from them any service incompatible with the parole given.
Art. 11. A
prisoner of war cannot be compelled to accept his liberty on
parole;
similarly the hostile Government is not obliged to accede to the
request
of the prisoner to be set at liberty on parole.
Art. 12. Prisoners
of war liberated on parole and recaptured bearing arms
against the
Government to whom they had pledged their honour, or against
the allies of
that Government, forfeit their right to be treated as
prisoners of war,
and can be brought before the courts.
Art. 13. Individuals who
follow an army without directly belonging to it,
such as newspaper
correspondents and reporters, sutlers and contractors,
who fall into the
enemy's hands and whom the latter thinks expedient to
detain, are entitled
to be treated as prisoners of war, provided they are
in possession of a
certificate from the military authorities of the army
which they were
accompanying.
Art. 14. An inquiry office for prisoners of war is
instituted on the
commencement of hostilities in each of the belligerent
States, and, when
necessary, in neutral countries which have received
belligerents in their
territory. It is the function of this office to
reply to all inquiries
about the prisoners. It receives from the various
services concerned full
information respecting internments and transfers.
releases on parole,
exchanges, escapes, admissions into hospital, deaths,
as well as other
information necessary to enable it to make out and keep
up to date an
individual return for each prisoner of war. The office must
state in this
return the regimental number, name and surname, age, place
of origin, rank,
unit, wounds, date and place of capture, internment,
wounding, and death,
as well as any observations of a special character.
The individual return
shall be sent to the Government of the other
belligerent after the
conclusion of peace.
It is likewise the
function of the inquiry office to receive and collect
all objects of
personal use, valuables, letters, etc., found on the field
of battle or
left by prisoners who have been released on parole, or
exchanged, or who
have escaped, or died in hospitals or ambulances, and to
forward them to
those concerned.
Art. 15. Relief societies for prisoners of war,
which are properly
constituted in accordance with the laws of their
country and with the
object of serving as the channel for charitable
effort shall receive from
the belligerents, for themselves and their duly
accredited agents every
facility for the efficient performance of their
humane task within the
bounds imposed by military necessities and
administrative regulations.
Agents of these societies may be admitted to
the places of internment for
the purpose of distributing relief, as also
to the halting places of
repatriated prisoners, if furnished with a
personal permit by the military
authorities, and on giving an undertaking
in writing to comply with all
measures of order and police which the
latter may issue.
Art. 16. Inquiry offices enjoy the privilege of
free postage. Letters,
money orders, and valuables, as well as parcels by
post, intended for
prisoners of war, or dispatched by them, shall be
exempt from all postal
duties in the countries of origin and destination,
as well as in the
countries they pass through.
Presents and
relief in kind for prisoners of war shall be admitted free of
all import
or other duties, as well as of payments for carriage by the
State
railways.
Art. 17. Officers taken prisoners shall receive the same
rate of pay as of
officers of corresponding rank in the country where they
are detained, the
amount to be ultimately refunded by their own
Government.
Art. 18. Prisoners of war shall enjoy complete liberty
in the exercise of
their religion, including attendance at the services of
whatever church
they may belong to, on the sole condition that they comply
with the
measures of order and police issued by the military
authorities.
Art. 19. The wills of prisoners of war are received or
drawn up in the same
way as for soldiers of the national army.
The
same rules shall be observed regarding death certificates as well as
for
the burial of prisoners of war, due regard being paid to their grade
and
rank.
Art. 20. After the conclusion of peace, the repatriation of
prisoners of
war shall be carried out as quickly as possible.
CHAPTER
III
The Sick and Wounded
Art. 21. The obligations of belligerents
with regard to the sick and
wounded are governed by the Geneva
Convention.
SECTION II
HOSTILITIES
CHAPTER I
Means of Injuring the
Enemy,
Sieges, and bombardments
Art. 22. The right of belligerents
to adopt means of injuring the enemy is
not unlimited.
Art. 23.
In addition to the prohibitions provided by special Conventions,
it is
especially forbidden -
(a)
To employ poison or poisoned weapons;
(b) to kill or wound treacherously individuals belonging to the
hostile
nation or army;
(c) To kill or wound an enemy who, having
laid down his arms, or having
no longer means of defence, has surrendered at discretion;
(d) To declare that no quarter will be
given;
(e) To employ arms,
projectiles, or material calculated to cause
unnecessary suffering;
(f) To make improper use of a flag of truce, of the national flag
or of
the military insignia
and uniform of the enemy, as well as the
distinctive badges of the Geneva Convention;
(g) To destroy or seize the enemy's property,
unless such destruction or
seizure be imperatively demanded by the necessities of war;
(h) To declare abolished, suspended, or
inadmissible in a court of law
the rights and actions of the nationals of the hostile party. A
belligerent is likewise forbidden to compel the nationals of the
hostile party to take part in the
operations of war directed against
their own country, even if they were in the belligerent's service
before the commencement of the war.
Art.
24. Ruses of war and the employment of measures necessary for
obtaining
information about the enemy and the country are considered
permissible.
Art.
25. The attack or bombardment, by whatever means, of towns, villages,
dwellings,
or buildings which are undefended is prohibited.
Art. 26. The
officer in command of an attacking force must, before
commencing a
bombardment, except in cases of assault, do all in his power
to warn the
authorities.
Art. 27. In sieges and bombardments all necessary steps
must be taken to
spare, as far as possible, buildings dedicated to
religion, art, science,
or charitable purposes, historic monuments,
hospitals, and places where the
sick and wounded are collected, provided
they are not being used at the
time for military purposes.
It
is the duty of the besieged to indicate the presence of such buildings
or
places by distinctive and visible signs, which shall be notified to the
enemy
beforehand.
Art. 28. The pillage of a town or place, even when taken
by assault, is
prohibited.
CHAPTER II
Spies
Art.
29. A person can only be considered a spy when, acting clandestinely
or on
false pretences, he obtains or endeavours to obtain information in
the
zone of operations of a belligerent, with the intention of
communicating
it to the hostile party.
Thus, soldiers not wearing a disguise who
have penetrated into the zone of
operations of the hostile army, for the
purpose of obtaining information,
are not considered spies. Similarly, the
following are not considered
spies: Soldiers and civilians, carrying out
their mission openly, entrusted
with the delivery of despatches intended
either for their own army or for
the enemy's army. To this class belong
likewise persons sent in balloons
for the purpose of carrying despatches
and, generally, of maintaining
communications between the different parts
of an army or a territory.
Art. 30. A spy taken in the act shall not
be punished without previous
trial.
Art. 31. A spy who, after
rejoining the army to which he belongs, is
subsequently captured by the
enemy, is treated as a prisoner of war, and
incurs no responsibility for
his previous acts of espionage.
CHAPTER III
Flags of
Truce
Art. 32. A person is regarded as a parlementaire who has been
authorized by
one of the belligerents to enter into communication with the
other, and who
advances bearing a white flag. He has a right to
inviolability, as well as
the trumpeter, bugler or drummer, the
flag-bearer and interpreter who may
accompany him.
Art. 33. The
commander to whom a parlementaire is sent is not in all cases
obliged to
receive him.
He may take all the necessary steps to prevent the
parlementaire taking
advantage of his mission to obtain information.
In
case of abuse, he has the right to detain the parlementaire temporarily.
Art.
34. The parlementaire loses his rights of inviolability if it is
proved in
a clear and incontestable manner that he has taken advantage of
his
privileged position to provoke or commit an act of treason.
CHAPTER IV
Capitulations
Art. 35. Capitulations agreed upon between the
Contracting Parties must
take into account the rules of military
honour.
Once settled, they must be scrupulously observed by both
parties.
CHAPTER V
Armistices
Art.
36. An armistice suspends military operations by mutual agreement
between
the belligerent parties. If its duration is not defined, the
belligerent
parties may resume operations at any time, provided always that
the enemy
is warned within the time agreed upon, in accordance with the
terms of the
armistice.
Art. 37. An armistice may be general or local. The first
suspends the
military operations of the belligerent States everywhere; the
second only
between certain fractions of the belligerent armies and within
a fixed
radius.
Art. 38. An armistice must be notified
officially and in good time to the
competent authorities and to the
troops. Hostilities are suspended
immediately after the notification, or
on the date fixed.
Art. 39. It rests with the Contracting Parties to
settle, in the terms of
the armistice, what communications may be held in
the theatre of war with
the inhabitants and between the inhabitants of one
belligerent State and
those of the other.
Art. 40. Any serious
violation of the armistice by one of the parties gives
the other party the
right of denouncing it, and even, in cases of urgency,
of recommencing
hostilities immediately.
Art. 41. A violation of the terms of the
armistice by private persons
acting on their own initiative only entitles
the injured party to demand
the punishment of the offenders or, if
necessary, compensation for the
losses sustained.
SECTION
III
MILITARY
AUTHORITY OVER THE TERRITORY
OF THE HOSTILE STATE
Art. 42.
Territory is considered occupied when it is actually placed under
the
authority of the hostile army.
The occupation extends only to the
territory where such authority has been
established and can be
exercised.
Art. 43. The authority of the legitimate power having in
fact passed into
the hands of the occupant, the latter shall take all the
measures in his
power to restore, and ensure, as far as possible, public
order and safety,
while respecting, unless absolutely prevented, the laws
in force in the
country.
Art. 44. A belligerent is forbidden to
force the inhabitants of territory
occupied by it to furnish information
about the army of the other
belligerent, or about its means of
defense.
Art. 45. It is forbidden to compel the inhabitants of
occupied territory to
swear allegiance to the hostile Power.
Art.
46. Family honour and rights, the lives of persons, and private
property,
as well as religious convictions and practice, must be respected.
Private
property cannot be confiscated.
Art. 47. Pillage is formally
forbidden.
Art. 48. If, in the territory occupied, the occupant
collects the taxes,
dues, and tolls imposed for the benefit of the State,
he shall do so, as
far as is possible, in accordance with the rules of
assessment and
incidence in force, and shall in consequence be bound to
defray the
expenses of the administration of the occupied territory to the
same extent
as the legitimate Government was so bound.
Art. 49.
If, in addition to the taxes mentioned in the above article, the
occupant
levies other money contributions in the occupied territory, this
shall
only be for the needs of the army or of the administration of the
territory
in question.
Art. 50. No general penalty, pecuniary or otherwise,
shall be inflicted
upon the population on account of the acts of
individuals for which they
cannot be regarded as jointly and severally
responsible.
Art. 51. No contribution shall be collected except
under a written order,
and on the responsibility of a
commander-in-chief.
The collection of the said contribution shall
only be effected as far as
possible in accordance with the rules of
assessment and incidence of the
taxes in force.
For every
contribution a receipt shall be given to the contributors.
Art. 52.
Requisitions in kind and services shall not be demanded from
municipalities
or inhabitants except for the needs of the army of
occupation. They shall
be in proportion to the resources of the country,
and of such a nature as
not to involve the inhabitants in the obligation of
taking part in
military operations against their own country.
Such requisitions and
services shall only be demanded on the authority of
the commander in the
locality occupied.
Contributions in kind shall as far as possible be
paid for in cash; if not,
a receipt shall be given and the payment of the
amount due shall be made as
soon as possible.
Art. 53. An army
of occupation can only take possession of cash, funds, and
realizable
securities which are strictly the property of the State, depots
of arms,
means of transport, stores and supplies, and, generally, all
movable
property belonging to the State which may be used for military
operations.
All
appliances, whether on land, at sea, or in the air, adapted for the
transmission
of news, or for the transport of persons or things, exclusive
of cases
governed by naval law, depots of arms, and, generally, all kinds
of
munitions of war, may be seized, even if they belong to private
individuals,
but must be restored and compensation fixed when peace is
made.
Art.
54. Submarine cables connecting an occupied territory with a neutral
territory
shall not be seized or destroyed except in the case of absolute
necessity.
They must likewise be restored and compensation fixed when peace
is
made.
Art. 55. The occupying State shall be regarded only as
administrator and
usufructuary of public buildings, real estate, forests,
and agricultural
estates belonging to the hostile State, and situated in
the occupied
country. It must safeguard the capital of these properties,
and administer
them in accordance with the rules of usufruct.
Art.
56. The property of municipalities, that of institutions dedicated to
religion,
charity and education, the arts and sciences, even when State
property,
shall be treated as private property.
All seizure of, destruction or
wilful damage done to institutions of this
character, historic monuments,
works of art and science, is forbidden, and
should be made the subject of
legal proceedings.